The Factor Online, All The Time
Is Hate Speech Protected?
By: BillOReilly.com Staff Thursday, October 7, 2010
So put yourself in this position: You lose a son in Iraq. He is killed fighting for his country. You arrange a funeral for him, an event that is emotionally devastating for your family and friends. Outside that funeral, a group of people hold signs saying that God killed your son because he fought for a country that "tolerates" homosexuals. Some of the protestors curse at people attending the service.

That's exactly what happened to Albert Snyder and his family in Maryland. In response, Mr. Snyder sued the leader of the hate group, Fred Phelps, and a jury awarded him millions. But the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in Virginia overturned the verdict on appeal and even imposed court costs on the Snyder family. The judges rationalized their misguided ruling by writing, "Although reasonable people may disagree about the appropriateness of the Phelps protest, this conduct simply does not satisfy the heavy burden required for the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress under Maryland law."

Reasonable people may disagree about the appropriateness of the Phelps protest? Are you kidding me? Who exactly thinks God wanted Matthew Snyder dead because America does not persecute gay people? Osama bin Laden?

The federal court's ruling is a legal ruse, a bunch of pinheaded mumbo-jumbo that seeks to justify injurious behavior under the guise of free speech. Forty-eight attorneys general have filed an amicus brief in support of the Snyder family. These prosecutors well understand that words can be used as weapons designed solely to harm American citizens. There is no "reasonable" debate in what the vicious protestors did. They intentionally wanted to inflict emotional distress on the grieving family of a dead soldier. That is against civil law.

One footnote: When Albert Snyder told the court he could not pay the court costs, Phelps told the press he should use his son's death benefits to satisfy the judgment. I hope those judges are sleeping well.

If Phelps and his crew had put forth that God wanted a soldier to die because his family was part of a minority group, the federal court ruling might have been different. Hate crime legislation was attached to the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and the legal system takes hateful action against minorities very seriously, as it should.

The Supreme Court is now hearing the Snyder-Phelps case and the outcome is important for all Americans. With the rise of the internet, cyber-bullying and threatening behavior has become a plague upon the land. Kids are committing suicide because they are humiliated on the net and anyone can be targeted by sick individuals. Inflicting emotional distress on another human being is just a mouse click away.

I well understand the slippery slope free speech argument being put forth by those who believe the federal judges did the right thing constitutionally. I make my living under the First Amendment, and I don't want the government telling me what I can and can't say. But evil is evil, and attacks are attacks. The Snyder family has a constitutional right to privacy and the pursuit of happiness. The despicable Phelps mob infringed on those rights.
Premium Member Comments
Only BillOReilly.com Premium Members can leave comments. Become a Premium Member to comment.
Appearances
MONDAY
TUESDAY
WEDNESDAY
THURSDAY
FRIDAY
SEPTEMBER 15, 2014  | PM Rating: A
Talking Points Memo
In Talking Points tonight, we'll discuss how to take the fight to ISIS and whether President...
Impact Segment
Brit responds to tonight's Talking Points on ISIS and whether President Obama can take them...
Personal Story Segment
A new poll from the Wall Street Journal and NBC News shows that Americans lack confidence in...
Factor Follow Up Segment
A new study shows that teenagers who smoke marijuana daily are 60% less likely to complete high...
Weekdays with Bernie Segment
More troubling news from the NFL: The Minnesota Vikings have reinstated running back Adrien...
Watters' World
We sent Watters out to Coney Island, Brooklyn to ask the folks what they make of some of the...
Get KP free when you become a PM!
Newsletters
Learn More about our newsletters here.
BillOReilly.com Column
Talking Points Memo Transcript
The Bill Bulletin
The Factor Insider
This Week on The Factor
E-mail Address
Follow The Factor
Terms & Conditions   |   Privacy Policy   |   Acknowledgements   |   Advertising   |   Mobile Site
Copyright © 2002-2014 BillOReilly.com. All rights reserved.