What the Eric Garner Case Says about America
By: Bill O'ReillyDecember 4, 2014
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter

First of all, we received some letters criticizing me, Charles Krauthammer, and other Fox News analysts for saying the grand jury's decision not to indict a New York City police officer in the death of Eric Garner may have been faulty.

Writing from Naples, Florida, Larry Ayers says:

"Regardless of the grand jury's verdicts, if Michael Brown and Eric Garner had not resisted and allowed themselves to be arrested, they would BOTH be alive today.  Simple as that!"

But of course, it's not as simple as that.

Yes, both deceased men should have cooperated with the police officers who confronted them.  But as we all know, people do stupid things.

In the Ferguson case, Mr. Brown engaged in violence, so I have no trouble with the grand jury's decision not to indict Darren Wilson.

But in the New York case, Mr. Garner, clearly a low-level offender, was not a threat.

American police are held to a high standard because they have power.

They must control inflammatory situations, not make them worse.

And as we proved on Monday, generally speaking, American police do a great job across the board.

The charlatans who say police are targeting young black men are completely shut down by the statistics, which we have posted on BillOReilly.com.

But in the Garner case, excessive force may have been used:

CHARLES KRAUTHAMMER, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR: “This has no connection with what happened in Ferguson.  From looking at the video, the grand jury's decision here is totally incomprehensible. It looks as if at least they might have indicted him on something like involuntary manslaughter, at the very least.”


BILL O’REILLY: “I will say that upon seeing the video that you just saw, and hearing Mr. Garner say he could not breathe, I was extremely troubled.  I would have loosened my grip.  I desperately wish the officer would have done that.”


JUDGE ANDREW NAPOLITANO, FOX NEWS JUDICIAL ANALYST: “This ought to have been an indictment and it ought to have been an indictment for some form of manslaughter. It’s not first degree murder, it’s not second degree murder, but it’s certainly reckless manslaughter.”

Unlike Judge Napolitano, I am unwilling to say that Officer Daniel Pantaleo committed reckless manslaughter.  What I will say is, there was a police overreaction to Mr. Garner.

And that should have been adjudicated in the court of law.

Now, onto the bigger picture

Last night in New York City, the NYPD did an amazing job of controlling protesters who wanted to disrupt the annual Christmas tree lighting ceremony.

They were chanting, “No justice, no tree.”

The New York police stopped the chaos, and conducted themselves in a restrained and ultra-professional manner, protecting property and the public.

Missouri Governor Jay Nixon, who totally botched the Ferguson situation, should take notice.

And so should Mayor de Blasio, who continues to denigrate his cops.

BILL DE BLASIO, NEW YORK CITY MAYOR (July 28): “If you talk about the last decade or so in this city, was race a factor and a problem in the relationship between police and community?  Obviously it was.”


DE BLASIO, (Dec. 4): “The relationship between the police and the community has to change. ((EDIT)) People need to know that black lives and brown lives matter as much as white lives.”

That's an amazing insult to the NYPD.

Now, I can tell you with certainty that many police officers here in New York City despise Mayor de Blasio.

They believe he is intimidated by the likes of Al Sharpton and does not support them.

So now we have a situation where the nation's largest city has a mayor who has lost the support of his 35,000-member police force.

That is a recipe for disaster.

So let's sum up, many analysts here at Fox News believe the Staten Island grand jury made a mistake in the Eric Garner death.

And the mayor of New York City is putting all residents in jeopardy by alienating his police department.

And that's the memo.